Is it or is it not?
Pitti Laminations:
CMP: 38.50.
Market Cap: 36Cr Free Float: 21Cr
Debt March 2010: 75Cr
Reserves: 50Cr
ROCE March 2010: 12.57%
Enterprise Value: 111Cr
If we look at Pitti Laminations based on 9 months earnings: Sales: 174.16Cr, PBDIT: 21.93Cr Net Profit: 5.59Cr. Here are the Dec Quarter results and lets look at them from a different set of eyes
As you can see:
1. March 2010 Pitti had a PBDIT/Sales Profit margin of 15.28% while for the 9 month period ending Dec 2010 PBDIT/Sales Profit margin is 12.59% so compared to last year this year Pitti is actually making less money as margins are down
This fact can also be confirmed if you compare (A):
On 9 months ending Dec 2010:sales of 174.16Cr Pitti has a PBDIT of: 21.93Cr
On year end March 2010: Sales of 152.99Cr Pitti has a PBDIT of 23.38Cr
So Pitti made more money last year at a PBDIT level on a lower sales level.
2. Depreciation as percentage of sales is down from 4.14% for year ending March 2010 to 2.69% for 9 months ending Dec 2010. This is helping Pitti report higher profits.
Conclusion: Pitti is doing as good as last year.. the only difference is the exceptional Expense item of 5.6Cr which had made Pitti report a loss. Actually Pitti's margins have contracted even as its topline is growing... Also looks like the expansion plans have been completed and depreciation levels and interest levels are dropping indicating that going forward we can expect Pitti to mainatain its current margins of 12.59% (PBDIT levels) at the same time report higher profits by keeping depreciation and interest expenses under check.
Stock prices will also react favorably as people look at topline and bottomline completely missing out the margin picture.. Hold on to your stocks as the stock seems to have been accumulated and will move up as it reports +ve numbers each quarter.
Archives
Archives